Ãå±±½ûµØ

2024-UNAT-1452

2024-UNAT-1452, Ousmane Tamba Dia

UNAT Held or UNDT Pronouncements

The UNAT held that the UNDT did not commit any error in procedure that affected the outcome of the case by partially denying the former staff member’s motions for production of additional evidence or by not granting him sufficient additional time to respond to the Secretary-General’s submissions.

The UNAT also concluded that the UNDT appropriately identified the contested decision as the 1 April 2022 decision finding him ineligible to participate in ASHI.  The UNAT observed that the former staff member himself identified this decision in both his UNDT application and his management evaluation request.

The former staff member was recruited and given a fixed-term appointment with UNICEF from 2016 until 2020.  Prior to this, he served with the World Health Organization (WHO) from 1997 to 2005 in consultancy and short-term appointments.  However, the UNAT held that this period of service with WHO could not be considered as continuous and counted towards the 10 years of contributory health insurance plan requirement, as it did not meet the qualifications for reinstatement outlined in Staff Rule 4.18.  Therefore, the UNAT determined that he could only be eligible to enroll in the ASHI programme if he had participated in a contributory health insurance plan of the United Nations for a minimum of 10 years.  Since he only participated in such a plan, in a fixed-term capacity, from 2016 until 2020, the UNAT concluded that he was not eligible to enroll in ASHI.

The UNAT dismissed the appeal and affirmed Judgment No. UNDT/2023/051. 

Decision Contested or Judgment Appealed

A former staff member of the United Nations Children’s Fund (UNICEF) contested the decision to find him ineligible to participate in the Organization’s after-service health insurance plan (ASHI).

In its Judgment No. UNDT/2023/051, the UNDT dismissed his application, concluding that the contested decision was lawful as he had not accumulated the required 10 years of contributory participation in a United Nations health insurance plan.  

Former staff member appealed. 

Legal Principle(s)

The UNAT will not interfere lightly with the broad discretion of the UNDT in its case management.  Additionally, the UNDT does not have to address each and every claim made by a litigant, particularly when a claim lacks merit.

The UNDT has the authority to individualize and define the contested administrative decision and identify what is in fact being contested and subject to judicial review.  A management evaluation response is considered a decision or action of a complementary nature to the administrative decision.

A party, in order to be successful on appeal, not only has to assert and show that the UNDT committed an error in procedure but also that this error affected the decision on the case.

The eligibility to participate in ASHI for a staff member recruited on or after 1 July 2007 is contingent on meeting the criteria outlined in Section 2.1(a)(ii) of ST/AI/2007/3, which requires having been a participant in a contributory health insurance plan of the United Nations for a minimum of ten years.  Moreover, a staff member who is re-employed is treated as having a new appointment without regard to any period of former service.

Outcome
Appeal dismissed on merits

OAJ prepared this case law summary for informational purposes only. It is no official record and should not be relied upon as an authoritative interpretation of the Tribunals' rulings. For the authoritative texts, please refer to the judgment or order rendered by the respective Tribunal. The Tribunals are the only bodies competent to interpret their respective judgments, as provided under Article 12(3) of the UNDT Statute and Article 11(3) of the UNAT Statute. Any inaccuracies in the publication are the sole responsibility of OAJ, which should be contacted directly for any correction requests. To provide comments, don't hesitate to get in touch with OAJ at oaj@un.org.

The judgment summaries were generally prepared in English. They were translated into French and are being reviewed for accuracy of the translation.