2014-UNAT-418, Guedes
UNAT addressed both appeals by the Secretary-General in judgment No. 2014-UNAT-418. UNAT held that UNDT did not commit an error of law when it accepted one of the possible reasonable interpretations of Staff Rule 5.3(e) and decided that the SLWOP did not affect the continuous duration of the staff member’s appointment. UNAT held that, contrary to the assertions made by the Secretary-General, the staff member had in fact an expectation of being granted a permanent appointment and that the evidence had been produced at the special hearing on 4 March 2013. UNAT dismissed the appeals and affirmed the UNDT judgments.
UNDT judgment: The Applicant contested the decision not to convert his appointment to a permanent appointment due to the fact that his six months Special Leave Without Pay (SLWOP) resulted in him not having acquired five years of continuous service on a fixed-term appointment under the 100-series of the Staff Rules by 30 June 2009. UNDT issued a judgment on liability and found that the decision to deny the Applicant’s conversion to a permanent appointment was unlawful and that it should, therefore, be rescinded. Later UNDT issued a judgment on relief and found that the Applicant had suffered distress and anxiety in the wake of the contested decision, but that the severity of the distress level was at the lower end of the scale. UNDT awarded the Applicant compensation for emotional harm.
General Assembly Resolution 37/126 of 17 December 1982 decided that upon completion of five years of continuing good service, staff members on fixed-term appointments shall be given every reasonable consideration for a career appointment. ST/SGB/2009/10, in Section 1, adds that to be eligible for consideration for conversion to a permanent appointment, a staff member must, by 30 June 2009: (a) Have completed, or complete, five years of continuous service on fixed-term appointments under the 100 series of the Staff Rules; and (b) Be under the age of 53 years on the date such staff member has completed or completes the five years of qualifying service.